Constitutional Court of Türkiye’s Annulment Decision on Article 128 of the Umumi Hıfzıssıhha Law
This article provides general information. Legislation, time limits and amounts may change over time; obtain an up-to-date assessment of your specific situation.
What legal debate did the annulment decision of the Constitutional Court bring to the agenda? Lawyer Gizem Gonce evaluated it.
The decision of the Constitutional Court dated 16 July 2026, numbered E.2025/144 and K.2026/164, was published in the Official Gazette dated 17 November 2026. The Supreme Court annulled the first sentence in the first paragraph of Article 128 of the General Hygiene Law No. 1593, finding it unconstitutional. The second sentence, which was no longer applicable due to the cancellation of the first sentence, was also canceled.
LAWYER GİZEM GONCE: “The regulatory authority of the public authority is limited to human dignity and fundamental rights.”
Question: Why is this decision of the Constitutional Court important?
The importance of the Constitutional Court decision is that it brings to the agenda again the limits of the public authority's regulatory and supervisory authority vis-à-vis fundamental rights. The state has the authority to protect public health, ensure social order and take necessary administrative measures. However, when using this authority, human dignity, the right to protect one's material and spiritual existence and basic constitutional guarantees cannot be ignored.
Question: What constitutional provisions did the court rely on?
The decision focused especially on Articles 5 and 17 of the Constitution. Article 5 of the Constitution imposes on the state the duty to protect the fundamental rights and freedoms of the individual and to prepare the necessary conditions for the development of the material and spiritual existence of the human being. Article 17 guarantees the right to protect and develop the person's material and spiritual existence.
The court concluded that the regulation in question was incompatible with these constitutional guarantees.
Question: Does this decision eliminate all regulations regarding prostitution?
No. It is necessary to evaluate the scope of the decision correctly. The canceled provisions are certain sentences contained in Article 128 of the General Hygiene Law. This decision does not mean that all legislation, administrative control mechanisms or criminal law provisions regarding prostitution are automatically abolished.
The legal effect of a Constitutional Court decision should be determined by evaluating the scope of the annulled provision and the provisions regarding the entry into force of the decision.
Question: What meaning does the decision have for citizens?
This decision reminds us that regulations that interfere with fundamental rights cannot be justified solely on the grounds of public interest. Protecting public health is, of course, the duty of the state. However, the tools used in performing this duty must also be in accordance with the Constitution.
What is important in the state of law is not only the supervision of an activity, but also the legal basis on which the supervision is carried out and within what limits.
Question: Finally, what legal conclusion should be drawn?
The basic message of this decision is that the state's obligation to protect the public interest and the fundamental rights of the individual are not alternatives to each other. While ensuring public order, human dignity and constitutional rights must be protected. The supervision of the Constitutional Court serves precisely to protect this border.