Can you recover mortgage instalments you paid for someone else’s home?

A person's payment of the installments of a loan used to purchase a real estate that does not belong to him/her can lead to serious legal disputes between the parties. Especially people who take on the loan debt of a house registered in someone else's name due to family relationships, cohabitation, preparation for marriage or a relationship of trust, wonder whether they can ask for the payments they made back when the relationship ends.

In the decision of the Supreme Court, which was reflected on the legal agenda on November 18, 2026, the approach that the compensation claim for loan installments should be evaluated separately, even if the fiduciary transaction cannot be proven, attracted attention. This evaluation is important in terms of the demands of people who cannot obtain ownership of the real estate but contribute to its financing.

In its judgment of 24 June 2026 (E. 2025/329, K. 2026/413), the General Assembly of Civil Chambers of Türkiye’s Court of Cassation set aside the lower court’s decision to adhere to its earlier ruling. The General Assembly held that the payment receipts and the parties’ statements had to be considered in deciding the claim for compensation covering the mortgage instalments. It made no final finding on whether the payments had been made or on any amount payable.

Lawyer Gizem Gonce uses the following statements in her legal assessment on the subject:

In whose name a real estate is registered in the title deed and who pays the payments made for the acquisition of the real estate are different legal issues. Just because the land registry is in the name of one person does not mean that all payments made by another person will be legally ignored. However, it cannot be said that the person making the payment directly acquires ownership rights on the real estate.

Here, it is first investigated whether there is a fiduciary transaction between the parties. The person claiming fiduciary transaction must prove with legally acceptable evidence that the immovable property was transferred to his/her own account or for his/her own benefit for a certain purpose and that the title deed is temporarily held in the name of another person. Failure to prove this claim does not automatically necessitate the rejection of all claims regarding payments made.

For example, a person may have regularly paid the loan installments of the house purchased in another person's name from his own bank account. In this case, it should be examined which legal relationship the payments are based on. Has a donation been made, has a loan been given, is there a common acquisition purpose, or is there another agreement between the parties? The answers to these questions determine the legal nature of the request.

Legal reasons such as unjust enrichment, management of another person’s affairs without a mandate or contractual receivables may arise depending on the characteristics of the concrete case. However, it should not be thought that a refund will be issued automatically for every payment.

Gonce emphasizes that in such disputes, bank receipts, loan payment records, messages between the parties and written agreements, if any, are of great importance. Especially the statements written in the explanation section of the payments and the will of the parties before the payment can be effective in resolving the dispute.

A person who pays for a real estate registered in someone else's name cannot be deprived of his rights just by looking at the land registry; However, he must base his request on the correct legal reason and concrete evidence.

Decision and legislation sources

Back to blog