How to File a Suit for Adjustment of Land Share?

Land shares concern millions of property owners and are particularly important in urban transformation projects. Two apartments in the same building may have similar floor areas but different land shares recorded in the title register. What criteria determine a land share? How can a lower land share allocated to one apartment be corrected? Can unfairly allocated land shares be challenged in court? Lawyer Gizem Gonce explained the legal aspects of land-share correction proceedings and property owners’ rights.

First, what is a land share? How should owners understand this proportion recorded in their title deeds?

A land share is the share of co-ownership allocated to an individually owned unit within a principal property.

For example, let's say there are 10 flats in an apartment building. The title deeds of each of these flats may contain different land shares such as 1000/10000, 1500/10000 or 500/10000.

These ratios show the extent of the common ownership right of the relevant independent section owner on the land of the main real estate.

I would like to correct an important misunderstanding: a land share is not determined solely by the apartment’s floor area. Factors such as the unit’s floor, location, orientation, use, architectural characteristics and economic value are also taken into account.

Article 3 of the Condominium Law No. 634 contains a clear regulation on this issue. According to the law, land shares must be proportional to the values ​​calculated according to the location and size of the independent sections.

A land share is therefore more than just a number in the title register. It is an important part of the owner’s property rights.

What is meant by an action to equalise land shares? Must everyone have the same land share?

First, the legal name of this action is an action for correction of land shares. It is commonly described as equalising or reallocating land shares.

There is an important distinction, however: correcting land shares does not mean making the shares of all apartments equal.

For example, it is not necessary that the land shares of a 100 square meter flat in an apartment building and a 180 square meter flat in a more advantageous location be the same.

In some cases, allocating equal land shares may even be unlawful.

The actual aim is to make the land share allocated to each unit proportionate to that unit’s value at the date when condominium ownership or the construction servitude was established.

If one apartment has been allocated a lower land share than it should have and another a higher share, a court application may be made to correct this disproportion.

In other words, the aim is not to give the same share to everyone, but to ensure a legal and equitable distribution.

What criteria are taken into account when determining land shares?

In this regard, it is not enough to just look at the square meters of the flats.

In the practice of the Supreme Court, it is accepted that various factors affecting the value of independent sections should be evaluated together.

Among them:

- Surface area of the independent section,

- Which floor of the building is it located on?

- Facade and sunlight exposure,

- View,

- Architectural features and usage style,

- Heating system,

- Enlightenment conditions,

- Location and usage advantages,

- The nature of the independent section, for example whether it is a residence or a workplace

There are criteria such as.

For example, let's assume that one of the two flats in the same building has a wide façade, better lighting and a more advantageous location, while the other is smaller and in a disadvantageous location.

It would not be correct to calculate only square meters when determining the land shares of these two independent sections.

Another important issue here is the evaluation date. As a rule, the court determines the values ​​on the date the floor easement was established; If a condominium is established directly without establishing a floor easement, it is based on the values ​​on the date the condominium was established.

Increases in value resulting from later renovations, zoning changes or appreciation of the surrounding area do not by themselves justify changing the land shares.

Why should an action be brought if a land share was allocated incorrectly? How can this harm the property owner?

An incorrectly allocated land share may affect both the property owner’s current rights and future economic interests.

It appears especially in three important areas.

The first is urban transformation and reconstruction processes.

When a building is demolished and rebuilt, the owners' ownership shares on the land become important. Incorrect determination of land shares may lead to disputes regarding the sharing of independent sections in the new project and the economic balance between the parties.

However, which owner receives which unit in a new project is not automatically determined in every case solely by the existing land share. The contracts, zoning status, project conditions and provisions of Law No. 6306 must also be assessed.

Second, the economic value of the real estate.

The land share indicates the extent of the co-ownership right attached to the unit. A land share that is set too low may therefore have significant economic consequences, particularly in areas with high land values.

Third, common expenses and management relationships.

Article 20 of the Condominium Ownership Law provides that some common expenses are shared in proportion to land shares, while others are divided equally.

For example, the land share is an important measure for the principal property’s insurance costs and the maintenance, protection and repair of common areas. By contrast, the costs of the caretaker, heating operator, gardener and security guard are generally shared equally.

An incorrect land share may therefore also produce unfair results in the allocation of certain expenses.

Why are land shares so important in urban transformation?

Urban transformation involves more than demolishing an old building and replacing it with a new one. It also requires reassessment of the owners’ property rights, economic interests and position within the new project.

For example, imagine two apartment owners in the same building.

Suppose the first apartment has a land share of 100/1000 and the second has a land share of 200/1000.

If these proportions were not initially set in proportion to the units’ values, serious disputes may arise during transformation, particularly in an area with high land values.

Owners should understand that the land share represents not just the floor area of their current apartment, but also their co-ownership right in the principal property.

However, the majority required for decisions in urban transformation is a separate legal issue from land-share correction proceedings. The current provisions of Law No. 6306 must be examined separately. Filing an action for correction of land shares does not automatically suspend transformation procedures.

Can someone who believes their land share is too low bring an action alone?

Yes. Article 3 of the Condominium Ownership Law gives every apartment owner or holder of a construction servitude the right to apply to court if land shares were not allocated in proportion to the units’ values.

They therefore do not need the other owners’ consent, a resolution of the owners’ assembly or action by the building management before proceeding.

An owner who believes their land share was allocated incorrectly may bring an action to protect their own legal interests.

The key is not simply to assert that the land share is low, but to demonstrate with concrete evidence that there was a genuine disproportion in light of the values at the date of establishment.

Is there a time limit for bringing an action?

Article 3 of the Condominium Ownership Law does not prescribe a specific forfeiture period for an action for correction of land shares.

As a rule, this action is therefore not subject to a specific limitation or forfeiture period.

However, I would like to highlight an important point. The legal situation may become more complex, particularly during urban transformation, demolition or reconstruction of a building.

In its judgment of 10 September 2025, case E. 2023/648, K. 2025/512, the General Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation considered demolition of the principal building while land-share correction proceedings were pending. It found that, in the particular case, demolition alone did not render the action moot.

Demolition therefore cannot be said to extinguish the right to bring an action in every case. However, legal and factual changes occurring before or during proceedings must be examined in the circumstances of the individual case.

My advice to owners who suspect an error in their land share is to avoid waiting until the final stage of urban transformation.

Which court hears an action for correction of land shares? Is mediation required first?

Since this case is a dispute arising from the Property Ownership Law, the competent court is the Civil Court of Peace.

The competent court is the court where the real estate is located. The jurisdiction of the court where the real estate is located is absolute.

In addition, within the scope of Article 18/B of the Law on Mediation in Civil Disputes No. 6325, it is a requirement to apply to a mediator before filing a lawsuit in disputes arising from the Property Ownership Law.

Accordingly, the mandatory mediation process must also be completed before bringing an action for correction of land shares.

If no agreement is reached in mediation, a final report is prepared and a lawsuit is filed with the necessary documents.

In this case, should all flat owners in the apartment be sued?

Yes, this issue is very important in terms of procedural law.

A decision correcting land shares affects more than just the claimant’s share. Increasing the land share of one unit also affects the shares of the other units and the balance of the total land shares.

For this reason, other flat owners or floor easement owners other than the plaintiff must be parties to the lawsuit.

For example, if an owner in a building with 12 apartments requests correction of their land share, the owners of the other units affected by the outcome must also be joined as parties.

For this reason, before filing a lawsuit, title deed records must be updated, all owners must be determined and parties must be properly formed.

How does the court determine during proceedings whether the land shares are correct?

The court attaches great importance to technical examination in such cases.

Generally, the review is carried out by a committee consisting of experts in the fields of real estate valuation, construction and, when necessary, architecture.

The expert panel first determines the date on which the floor easement or condominium was established. Then, it examines the characteristics and values ​​of the independent sections at that time.

Land registry records, floor easement or condominium establishment documents, architectural projects, municipal records, qualifications of independent sections and other technical documents are evaluated.

The Supreme Court has an important approach here: Land shares cannot be redetermined by only making an abstract evaluation. The value of each independent section should be revealed separately and compared with the existing land shares.

These criteria were also drawn to attention in the decision of the 20th Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Appeals dated July 6, 2020, numbered 2020/87 E. and 2020/2489 K..

What happens if the action for correction of land shares succeeds?

If the court determines that the land shares allocated to independent sections are not proportional to the initial values, it may decide to rearrange the land shares.

Once the decision becomes final, the necessary corrections in the land registry become a priority.

For example, if it is established that one apartment was initially allocated less than its proper land share and another received too much, this disproportion may be corrected.

I would like to emphasise again that the court’s aim is not to give every apartment an equal land share. The aim is to ensure that each unit has a land share corresponding to its actual value at the date of establishment.

What should citizens pay particular attention to when checking their title deeds?

I recommend that owners first check the land share recorded in their title deeds.

Particularly in older buildings, apartments of the same size may have been allocated different land shares, while apartments with different characteristics may have been assigned the same share without justification.

It will be useful for citizens to examine the following documents:

- Current title deed records,

- Condominium ownership or floor easement establishment documents,

- Management plan,

- Approved architectural project,

- Numbers and qualities of independent sections,

- Records showing the distribution of land shares on the date of establishment.

Especially if urban transformation is on the agenda in a building or there is a dispute about the rights of the owners over the new project, the legal review should not be delayed.

IMPORTANT WARNING FROM LAWYER GİZEM GONCE TO PROPERTY OWNERS

A land share may seem like a proportion recorded in the title register that owners rarely consider. Yet it is an important factor determining the extent of the owner’s property rights in the underlying land.

Particularly in old buildings, the initial determination of land shares incorrectly or disproportionately can lead to serious disputes when urban transformation comes to the fore years later.

Owners should not assume their land shares are correct merely by looking at the floor area of their apartments. The values at the date condominium ownership was established, the land registry records and the characteristics of the units must be assessed together.

A land share is more than a land registry entry: it is an important part of the owner’s property rights and future economic interests. If your entitlement has been understated, the law allows you to apply to court.

Related articles

Official sources and legislation

Back to blog