Eleven Divorce Judgments: Fault, Evidence and Compensation
This article provides general information. Legislation, time limits and amounts may change over time; obtain an up-to-date assessment of your specific situation.
Short headlines about divorce may not capture a judgment’s full reasoning. This review examines eleven 2nd Civil Chamber judgments from 2019–2026 using the facts and outcomes in their official texts. A judgment’s date must be distinguished from the date a news report appeared.
1. Smoking around an ill spouse and failing to provide support in hospital
The case decided on 18.10.2023, E.2023/1894, K.2023/4841, involved known health problems, smoking at home, lack of attention during hospital treatment and abandonment of shared life. The judgment upheld on further appeal illustrates assessment of the proven events together, rather than an automatic outcome from a single behaviour.
Knowledge of the illness, the spouse’s conduct and its effect on shared life matter under the mutual assistance duty in Civil Code Article 185. Blaming a person for being ill is distinct from assessing the other spouse’s failure to provide support.
2. Psychological pressure over a future inheritance
In E.2025/7951, K.2026/3574 of 02.04.2026, repeated pressure by the husband on his wife and her living father concerning inheritance was assessed alongside insults. The decision was quashed in the wife’s favour on fault and non-pecuniary compensation. The focus was conduct harming personality rights, not the mere existence of an expectation of inheritance.
3. Pre-marital correspondence and retaining messages
In E.2026/2188, K.2026/8302 of 21.09.2026, the court noted that correspondence from 2014 predated the marriage in 2020, so the correspondence itself could not be attributed as marital fault. Retaining the messages was considered alongside the other conduct in the case. The equal-fault conclusion remained and the decision was upheld.
This case-specific assessment does not mean that keeping any old message produces the same outcome in every case. Alleged events, context, dates, completeness and lawful acquisition must be assessed together.
4. A heart emoji and an unlawfully obtained audio recording
In E.2025/5186, K.2025/7559 of 18.09.2025, an emoji sent to a social media personality as an expression of liking was not properly characterised as trust-undermining conduct in that case. An unlawful ambient audio recording could not support the judgment either. The husband’s proven conduct was assessed together and the decision on fault was quashed in the wife’s favour.
5. Borrowing to meet household needs
In E.2026/1300, K.2026/7429 of 30.06.2026, the evidence established that the husband failed to meet household needs. The wife’s debts to a haberdashery and grocery store were not properly attributable to her as fault. Going to stay with the parties’ child and not returning was also assessed in the particular proceedings. Other established misconduct supported retaining the finding of greater fault on the husband’s part.
Under Civil Code Article 186, spouses contribute to common expenses through work and assets according to their means. Borrowing varies in nature; purpose, necessity and effects on the family budget should be documented.
6. Repeated insults and mutual physical violence
In E.2025/6449, K.2026/892 of 02.02.2026, the husband’s repeated insults, alcohol use adversely affecting family life and the mutual nature of physical violence were assessed together. Equal fault was rejected; the husband bore greater fault, and the decision was also quashed in the wife’s favour on compensation.
The judgment is not a general rule minimising physical violence. Severity, persistence, mutual conduct and effects on the individuals must be evaluated across the entire case. Mechanically comparing counts of violence and insults is insufficient.
7. Fault and the scope of appeal in a case involving snoring
In E.2017/4108, K.2019/663 of 06.02.2019, separate sleeping arrangements, marital duties, insults and other events were considered. Which findings of fault had been challenged by a regional appeal also mattered. The chamber upheld the judgment while correcting its reasoning on fault.
A health symptom is distinct from the other spouse’s response to it. The conduct pleaded, proof and parts of the judgment challenged on appeal affect the result. A general conclusion about divorce or compensation cannot be drawn from the headline “snoring” alone.
8. Neglect of an ill spouse and dismissal of the claim
The proceedings in E.2024/745, K.2024/7992 of 30.10.2024 concerned neglect of a wife with diabetes and loss of vision. The husband’s divorce claim was dismissed because his allegations of fault against her were not proved and his own misconduct was established; that decision was upheld. The outcome should not be reported as a divorce granted because an ill spouse was neglected.
9. Withholding income from the family and taking the children’s money
In E.2025/5976, K.2026/658 of 20.01.2026, the husband’s failure to use income for the home, repeated insults and threats, trust-undermining conduct and taking money from his children’s pockets without their knowledge were assessed together. Equal fault was incorrect: he bore greater fault and the wife less. The decision rejecting her pecuniary and non-pecuniary compensation claims was quashed.
10. Restricting basic needs and allegations of excessive stinginess
The case in E.2023/7873, K.2024/6154 of 19.09.2024 included allegations of restricting lighting, water use, food and household needs. The appealed judgment was upheld. A preference for saving money must be distinguished from humiliating or coercive conduct preventing a spouse from meeting basic needs.
11. The effect of coffeehouse habits on family responsibilities
In E.2024/49, K.2024/8645 of 18.11.2024, time spent at a coffeehouse, violence, humiliation and other family conduct were assessed together. A finding against the wife had to be removed in light of witness evidence, resulting in greater fault on the husband’s part. The decision was quashed in her favour on fault and pecuniary and non-pecuniary compensation.
How should these judgments be read together?
Breakdown of marriage under Article 166 and compensation requirements under Article 174 of the Civil Code require separate examination. Courts decide on pleaded and proved events. Pleadings and appeals, witnesses’ direct knowledge, lawful correspondence evidence and whether earlier events were forgiven matter. The outcome of one judgment is not an automatic outcome for every case with a similar headline.
Official sources and judgments
- 2nd Civil Chamber, 18.10.2023, E.2023/1894, K.2023/4841
- 2nd Civil Chamber, 02.04.2026, E.2025/7951, K.2026/3574
- 2nd Civil Chamber, 21.09.2026, E.2026/2188, K.2026/8302
- 2nd Civil Chamber, 18.09.2025, E.2025/5186, K.2025/7559
- 2nd Civil Chamber, 30.06.2026, E.2026/1300, K.2026/7429
- 2nd Civil Chamber, 02.02.2026, E.2025/6449, K.2026/892
- 2nd Civil Chamber, 06.02.2019, E.2017/4108, K.2019/663
- 2nd Civil Chamber, 30.10.2024, E.2024/745, K.2024/7992
- 2nd Civil Chamber, 20.01.2026, E.2025/5976, K.2026/658
- 2nd Civil Chamber, 19.09.2024, E.2023/7873, K.2024/6154
- 2nd Civil Chamber, 18.11.2024, E.2024/49, K.2024/8645
- Turkish Civil Code No. 4721
- Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100