Does Sending Flowers Constitute the Crime of Sexual Harassment?
Does sending flowers constitute the crime of sexual harassment? This question has frequently come to the agenda with recent rulings by the Court of Cassation. In particular, sending flowers to a person with a note saying "you are always on my mind" and subsequent stalking behaviors directly affect the legal assessment. Therefore, the conditions of each concrete case are examined separately.
Court of Cassation Ruling: Is Sending Flowers a Crime on Its Own?
In a case heard in Afyonkarahisar, the defendant sent flowers to a woman he liked with a note saying, "you are always on my mind." In addition, the defendant drove around the site where the victim lived on different dates. The court of first instance evaluated these actions within the scope of sexual harassment.
However, the file went to appellate review. The 12th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation ruled that the defendant's actions did not constitute the crime of sexual harassment. Conversely, the court evaluated the actions within the scope of the crime of disturbing the peace and tranquility of persons and upheld the sentence imposed.
Conditions for the Crime of Sexual Harassment (TCC Art. 105)
According to the Turkish Penal Code, certain conditions must be met for an act to be considered sexual harassment:
- The perpetrator acts with a sexual purpose
- The victim is clearly disturbed
- The behavior is persistent or of an inappropriate nature
If these three elements occur together, the crime of sexual harassment comes to the fore.
When Does Sending Flowers Not Constitute a Crime?
Not every act of sending flowers constitutes a crime. In the following cases, criminal liability generally does not arise:
- It is sent as a one-time occurrence
- The message contains no sexual content
- It is intended for congratulations, get-well wishes, or an apology
- There is communication between the parties and no discomfort is caused
For example, a bouquet sent with a "get well soon" note is considered legal in most cases.
When Does Sending Flowers Constitute a Crime?
Conversely, some situations cross the legal boundary. A crime may occur, especially in the following cases:
- The victim clearly states that they do not want it
- The perpetrator continues to send flowers persistently despite this
- The sent note contains sexual content or implications
- The perpetrator physically stalks the victim
In this case, the court evaluates the act within the scope of stalking, sexual harassment, or disturbing the peace and tranquility of persons.
Crime of Disturbing the Peace and Tranquility of Persons (TCC Art. 123)
If the perpetrator constantly disturbs a person, this crime occurs. In particular:
- Sending constant messages
- Stalking
- Going to the same places
- Communicating persistently
such behaviors constitute this crime.
In the Court of Cassation ruling, the court also evaluated the defendant's behaviors within this scope.
What Criteria Do Courts Look At?
Courts examine the following elements in every concrete case:
- Number of shipments (is there persistence?)
- Content of the message (does it contain sexual meaning?)
- Relationship between the parties
- The victim's clear discomfort
- Prior warning or blocking
These criteria directly determine whether the act is a crime.
Conclusion: Sending Flowers Is Not Always a Crime
The answer to the question, "Does sending flowers constitute the crime of sexual harassment?" is clear:
🔴 Sending flowers alone does not constitute a crime
🔴 However, if there is persistence and stalking, a crime is committed
🔴 If there is a sexual purpose, sexual harassment comes to the fore
🔴 If there is constant disturbance, the crime of disturbing the peace and tranquility occurs
Therefore, the manner and continuity of the behavior determine the legal outcome.
For Detailed Information, Please Contact Us!