Can an online marketplace close a customer’s account unilaterally?

One of the problems that consumers who shop online may encounter is the sudden closure of the membership or customer account on the e-commerce platform. When the consumer cannot access his account, he may not be able to track his orders, manage the return process, or may have difficulty accessing past shopping records. This raises the question under what conditions platforms can close user accounts.

E-commerce sites offer their services within the framework of certain membership and usage conditions. It may be possible for the platform to take some precautions if users violate these conditions, create fake accounts, abuse the system or create a security risk. However, this authority is not unlimited.

Lawyer Gizem Gonce states that account closure procedures in consumer law should be evaluated based on concrete events:

In order for an e-commerce platform to close a membership account, it must first be checked whether there is a contractual basis, the reason for closure, and whether the transaction applied is proportionate. Not every provision in the terms of use of the platform automatically becomes lawful just because it is written in the contract.

Within the scope of the Law on Consumer Protection No. 6502, provisions added to the contract without negotiation with the consumer and creating an imbalance against the rule of honesty to the detriment of the consumer may be considered unfair terms. For this reason, provisions that allow the platform to close the consumer's account at its sole discretion, without giving any reason, will be open to legal audit.

Here, ongoing orders, paid amounts, refund requests, warranty rights and the consumer's access to past transaction records are particularly important. Closing the account does not eliminate the consumer's previously acquired rights. For example, if the consumer has exercised his/her right of withdrawal for a product in due time, he/she is not deemed to have given up his/her request for a refund due to the closure of his/her account.

The platform may temporarily limit the account due to security or suspicion of abuse. However, this transaction must be based on a concrete and reasonable justification, must not increase the consumer's grievance, and must be explainable to the extent possible. In particular, keeping the consumer's money on the platform or preventing an ongoing refund transaction should also be evaluated.

Gonce recommends that consumers whose accounts have been closed first make a written application to the platform and request the reason for the closure and transaction records, if any. If the problem is not resolved, consumer arbitration committee or consumer court remedies may be brought to the agenda, depending on the nature and monetary limit of the dispute.

Digital platforms have the freedom to provide services; However, this freedom does not eliminate the consumer's rights arising from the law.

Resources

Back to blog