Can a criminal case be heard again after the court issues its written reasons?

Announcement of the reasoned decision in a criminal case is one of the important stages of the trial process. However, one of the issues frequently wondered by the public is whether the case can be heard again after the reasoned decision is announced. Especially in comprehensive files with many defendants and different accusations, the question of whether the legal process has ended with the announcement of the decision comes to the fore.

The 2,130-page reasoned decision in the Aziz İhsan Aktaş case, which was published in the press on November 18, 2026, brought this debate to the agenda again. It was reported that the decision of the Istanbul 1st High Criminal Court included the defenses of the defendants, witness statements and evaluations regarding 63 separate actions. However, the announcement of the reasoned decision alone does not mean that the case will be heard again.

Lawyer Gizem Gonce draws attention to the following points in her legal assessment on the subject:

In criminal proceedings, the reasoned decision reveals what conclusion the court reached based on what evidence. With the announcement of this decision, the parties have the opportunity to evaluate whether the decision complies with the law and the scope of the file. However, retrial and resorting to legal remedies are different legal mechanisms.

First of all, the nature of the decision and its finality should be considered. Against a decision that has not yet become final, appeals and appeals may be filed under the conditions stipulated by law. At this stage, the superior court may review the decision; may find the provision lawful, remove or overturn it. The consequences of the decision to overturn or remove are determined according to the nature of the file and the relevant legal provisions.

On the other hand, after the verdict becomes final, ordinary legal remedies can no longer be resorted to. At this stage, retrial can only be brought to the agenda if the conditions limited in the law are met. Renewal of the trial regulated in Article 311 of the Code of Criminal Procedure; It is based on certain reasons, such as the discovery of the forgery of a document on which the verdict is based, or new events or evidence that may require the convict to be acquitted or receive a lighter sentence.

Therefore, merely announcing the reasoned decision or dissatisfaction of one of the parties with the decision is not sufficient for the case to be retried. The verdict must be evaluated separately for each defendant, the application period must not be missed, and the legal objections to be raised must be concrete.

Gonce emphasizes that the legal status of each defendant should be evaluated separately, especially in cases with multiple defendants, and says, "Different decisions may have been made about more than one person in a file. For this reason, it is not right to accept the legal status of all defendants as the same with a single general evaluation."

What is decisive in the legal process is not the announcement of the reasoned decision; The content of the decision, its finalization status and legal application conditions.

Resources

Back to blog