Migrant Smuggling: Offence and Penalties under Article 79 of the Turkish Criminal Code

Bringing foreigners into the country illegally, allowing them to stay in the country, or taking people abroad illegally has serious criminal law consequences. Within the scope of the crime of immigrant smuggling, not only the organizers but also those who knowingly participate in the action and by creating the elements of the crime may face criminal liability. So, what exactly constitutes immigrant smuggling? Is it a crime to transport a person in a vehicle, to shelter him in his home or to facilitate illegal passage? How much is the penalty for the crime? In which court are the captured people tried? Lawyer Gizem Gonce evaluated all aspects of the crime of immigrant smuggling and the trial process within the scope of the Turkish Penal Code.

What is the crime of immigrant smuggling? Under which law is it regulated in Turkish law?

Immigrant smuggling is a serious crime regulated in Article 79 of the Turkish Penal Code No. 5237 and included in the international crimes section.

In accordance with the law, in order to obtain financial benefit directly or indirectly, through illegal means;

- Bringing a foreigner into Türkiye,

- Allowing a foreigner to stay in Türkiye illegally,

- Allowing a Turkish citizen or foreigner to go abroad illegally

It may constitute the crime of immigrant smuggling.

What should be particularly noted here is that it is not necessary to receive money directly for a crime to occur. The law considers the purpose of obtaining direct or indirect financial benefit sufficient.

For example, if a person establishes an organization to bring foreign nationals into the country illegally, provides transportation, mediates their accommodation, or aims to gain indirect economic gain from these activities, it may be considered a crime depending on the characteristics of the incident.

This crime is not limited to people crossing the border. Activities that enable foreigners to stay in the country illegally are also within the scope of the law.

Does money have to be received for the crime of immigrant smuggling to occur?

No. What is important here is the aim of obtaining material benefit.

Article 79 of the Turkish Penal Code requires acting with the aim of obtaining financial benefit, directly or indirectly.

For example, a person may have agreed to receive money in exchange for illegally transporting foreign nationals abroad, but was caught before the planned transit took place.

In this case, the fact that the crime remains at the attempted stage does not eliminate the criminal responsibility of the person. Because Article 79 of the Turkish Penal Code brings a special regulation and states that even if the crime remains at the attempted stage, the penalty will be imposed as if it were completed.

However, a distinction must be made here. The mere fact that a person helps a migrant or is in the same vehicle with him does not automatically constitute the crime of smuggling migrants. The purpose of material gain, the performance of one of the optional actions specified in the law, and the person's intent must be demonstrated with concrete evidence.

Therefore, each event must be evaluated on its own terms.

Is transporting a foreigner in a vehicle considered an immigrant smuggling crime?

The answer to this question depends on the purpose of the transport and all the circumstances of the case.

For example, if a person transports foreign nationals within the scope of an illegal border crossing organization and aims to gain financial benefit from this activity, Article 79 of the Turkish Penal Code may come into question.

However, an ordinary vehicle journey, taxi service or transportation of a foreign person does not constitute this crime on its own.

In the criminal investigation, the person's role in the organization, his connection with other suspects, communication records, money transfers, the purpose of the transportation and the legal status of the foreigners are examined together.

In particular, it is not legally correct to consider vehicle drivers guilty solely on the grounds that there are foreign nationals in the vehicle. Criminal liability is personal and each suspect's criminal intent and action must be evaluated separately.

Does hosting a foreigner at home or at work constitute a crime of immigrant smuggling?

In some cases it can.

Article 79 of the Turkish Penal Code criminalizes not only the illegal entry of foreigners into the country, but also the illegal means of allowing them to stay in the country.

For example, if a person systematically provides shelter, concealment or organizational services to ensure that a foreigner, whose legal right to stay in Türkiye has expired, remains in the country, and does this for the purpose of obtaining financial benefit, the crime of immigrant smuggling may come to the fore.

However, there is a very important detail here: Renting a house to a foreigner, establishing a business relationship with him or helping him temporarily shelter is not, on its own, a crime of immigrant smuggling.

The legal status of the person, the purpose of the hosting activity, the relationship of financial interest and the intent of the perpetrator must be investigated.

For example, it is important whether the landlord knows the tenant's immigration status, whether he is part of an organization intended to facilitate illegal stay, and whether he has a financial interest purpose.

What is the penalty for immigrant smuggling?

The sanctions for this crime are quite severe.

According to the current regulation of Article 79 of the Turkish Penal Code, the person who commits the crime of immigrant smuggling:

It is punishable by imprisonment from five to eight years and a judicial fine from one thousand days to ten thousand days.

Here, both imprisonment and judicial fines are prescribed together.

Judicial fine is calculated by multiplying the number of days determined by the court and the daily amount to be applied as of the date of the crime. Therefore, the exact amount of the fine is determined according to the concrete file and the applicable legal regulation.

Additionally, the penalty is increased if the crime is committed under certain aggravating circumstances.

In what cases is the penalty for immigrant smuggling increased?

There are three important aggravating regulations in Article 79 of the Turkish Penal Code.

First: Endangering the lives of immigrants.

The penalty to be imposed for actions that pose a danger to the life of immigrants is increased by half to two-thirds.

For example, putting a large number of people on a boat carrying more passengers than its capacity, making a dangerous journey without taking into account sea conditions and safety precautions, or carrying people in airless and unsafe vehicles can be evaluated in this context.

However, in every case, the danger to life must be demonstrated with concrete conditions.

Second: Subjecting immigrants to degrading treatment.

In cases where immigrants are transported, kept or accommodated in conditions incompatible with human dignity, the penalty may be increased from half to two-thirds.

For example, it is important in this respect that people are transported in truck beds without air, kept in inhumane conditions, or housed in environments where their physical and human needs are not met.

Third: The crime is committed by more than one person or within the framework of organizational activities.

If the crime is committed by more than one person, the penalty is increased by half.

If it is committed within the framework of the activities of a criminal organization, the penalty is increased from half to one fold.

Here, acting together by more than one person and acting within the scope of the activities of a criminal organization are different legal evaluations.

Is it possible to attempt the crime of immigrant smuggling? Will immigrants be punished if they are caught before they can be passed through the border?

Yes. This is one of the issues that needs particular attention in terms of this crime.

Article 79 of the Turkish Penal Code clearly states that even if the crime remains at the attempted stage, the penalty will be imposed as if it were completed.

For example, an organization may have been made to take a group of foreigners abroad illegally, a transportation vehicle may have been prepared and the people may have been taken to the border region. However, the activity may have been stopped before the transition took place due to the intervention of the security forces.

Unlike the general attempt provisions, remaining at the attempt stage due to the special regulation in Article 79 of the Turkish Penal Code does not enable the basic penalty to be reduced for this reason alone.

However, the action carried out by the perpetrator, his purpose for financial gain and his participation in the crime must be demonstrated with concrete evidence.

Are immigrant smuggling and human trafficking the same crime?

No. It is extremely important to distinguish these two crimes.

Immigrant smuggling is regulated in Article 79 of the Turkish Penal Code, and human trafficking is regulated in Article 80.

The main aim of immigrant smuggling is to ensure illegal immigration and to obtain financial benefits.

In human trafficking, people are forced to work, forced to serve, forced into prostitution, exploited for slavery or similar purposes.

Methods such as force, threat, pressure, abuse of influence or taking advantage of people's helplessness in human trafficking are regulated by law.

For example, bringing a person into the country illegally may be considered within the scope of immigrant smuggling. However, subsequent forced labor or detention of the same person for exploitation may also constitute the crime of human trafficking, depending on the characteristics of the incident.

Therefore, elements of both crimes may be present in one incident. In such a case, the sum of the crimes and the responsibility of the perpetrator should be evaluated according to the characteristics of the concrete incident.

It is important for citizens to know this distinction. Because immigrant smuggling and human trafficking are not the same legal concept.

Are foreign persons subject to immigrant smuggling also considered criminals?

No. The legal status of the perpetrator of the crime of immigrant smuggling and the foreign persons who are the subject of this activity should be distinguished.

The fact that a foreigner has entered the country illegally does not automatically make him a perpetrator of the crime of immigrant smuggling.

Article 79 of the Turkish Penal Code regulates the criminal liability of persons who organize, facilitate or participate in illegal migration under the conditions set forth in the law.

Administrative obligations of foreigners regarding their entry, residence and exit from the country can also be evaluated within the scope of the Foreigners and International Protection Law No. 6458.

For example, administrative detention, deportation or other administrative action may be taken against a foreigner. However, these proceedings and criminal proceedings are different processes.

Particularly for persons applying for international protection, the principle of non-refoulement and other legal safeguards should also be taken into account.

Is the crime of immigrant smuggling dependent on a complaint? Can the prosecutor's office initiate an investigation on its own?

Immigrant smuggling is not a complaint-based crime.

Therefore, a person's filing a complaint is not a mandatory condition for the investigation of a crime.

The public prosecutor's office may initiate an investigation ex officio if it receives information about a crime being committed, through a tip-off, law enforcement detection, or any other means.

For example, if an illegal crossing organization is detected during a border security operation, the prosecutor's office can carry out investigations without waiting for a complaint from any victim.

For this reason, denunciations, law enforcement reports, technical surveillance records and other evidence have an important place in immigrant smuggling files.

How is an immigrant smuggling investigation conducted?

The investigation phase is extremely important in revealing all aspects of the crime.

The process is usually initiated by the chief public prosecutor's office upon detection or notice by law enforcement forces.

The following actions may come to the fore during the investigation:

1. Determining the identity and address information of the suspects,

2. Taking statements from immigrants,

3. Conducting inspections of vehicles, boats and other transportation vehicles,

4. Examining phone calls and messaging records in accordance with the law,

5. Investigating bank movements and money transfers,

6. Collection of camera records,

7. Investigating the connections and organizational structure between the suspects,

8. Conducting expert examination when necessary.

Especially in these files, determining the roles of the suspects within the organization is of great importance.

Being a driver of a vehicle, owning a house, or having a phone conversation with another person is not enough for a conviction.

The prosecutor's office must investigate whether the person knowingly and willingly committed the legal elements of the crime.

In addition, protective measures such as wiretapping, detecting communications, monitoring with technical means and seizing assets can only be implemented under the relevant legal conditions and, when necessary, by a judge's decision. These measures are not automatically applied to every file.

Are the people caught arrested? Is arrest an automatic consequence?

No. Just because a person is detained on suspicion of immigrant smuggling does not necessarily mean that he or she will be arrested.

Detention is subject to the conditions set out in Article 100 and the following of the Criminal Procedure Code No. 5271.

There must be concrete evidence showing a strong suspicion of crime, and there must also be grounds for arrest prescribed by law.

Issues such as the suspicion of escape and the possibility of destroying or altering evidence are evaluated.

Arrest is not a punishment, it is a protective measure. For this reason, the principle of proportionality should be observed and it should be evaluated whether lighter measures such as judicial control will be sufficient.

Each suspect's situation must be considered individually. A person's position in the organization, the condition of the evidence, their permanent residence, and their behavior during the investigation are important.

Which court has jurisdiction and authority for the crime of immigrant smuggling?

The competent court is determined within the framework of the nature of the crime and the penalty limits prescribed by law. The court responsible for the basic crime in Article 79 of the Turkish Penal Code is the Criminal Court of First Instance.

In the decision of the General Criminal Assembly of the Supreme Court of Appeals dated February 4, 2026, numbered 2024/160 E. and 2026/67 K., it is seen that the trial regarding the crime of immigrant smuggling is carried out in the Criminal Court of First Instance.

As a general rule, the competent court is the court where the crime was committed.

In events that take place in more than one place or within the scope of organized activity, the rules of authority are examined separately.

What is examined in court after a criminal case is opened?

If the public prosecutor's office obtains sufficient evidence to create suspicion as a result of the investigation, it issues an indictment. The prosecution phase begins when the indictment is accepted by the court.

During the trial, the court first evaluates whether the elements of the crime are present.

In particular, the following questions need to be answered:

- Has the suspect engaged in illegal entry, stay in the country or departure abroad?

- Is there a purpose to gain financial benefit?

- Did the suspect participate in this activity knowingly and willingly?

- Has there been a danger to the lives of immigrants?

- Is there any degrading treatment?

- Was the action carried out with more than one person or within the scope of organizational activity?

- Is there legal evidence supporting the alleged actions?

The court should not be satisfied with just law enforcement reports; All evidence must be evaluated together.

The defendant's right to defence, right to hear witnesses, right to make statements against evidence and fair trial guarantees must be protected.

It is also important to provide interpreter support in a language that foreign nationals can understand while their statements are being taken.

What evidence can be used against people tried for this crime?

In immigrant smuggling files, the quality of the evidence and its legal acquisition is of great importance.

For example:

- Statements of immigrants,

- Phone calls of suspects,

- Messaging and communication records,

- Bank account movements,

- Money transfers,

- Vehicle tracking and location records,

- Camera images,

- Vehicle or boat inspection reports,

- Border security and law enforcement reports,

- Statements of other suspects

It can be considered as evidence depending on the nature of the file.

However, having another suspect's number on a person's phone or being present at the scene alone does not prove that a crime has been committed.

Conviction in criminal proceedings must be based on sufficient evidence obtained in accordance with the law and revealing the elements of the crime.

In particular, the method of obtaining communication records, the legality of search and seizure procedures, identification procedures and translation processes are important for the defense.

Can vehicles used in immigrant smuggling be confiscated?

Yes, but here it is necessary to distinguish between the concepts of seizure and confiscation.

In terms of the tools used in the crime, the provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure and the Turkish Penal Code regarding confiscation may come to the fore.

For example, a boat or vehicle used to transport illegal immigrants may be kept as evidence during the investigation.

However, just because the vehicle was used in a crime does not mean that it will automatically be confiscated in all cases.

The goods confiscation conditions in Article 54 of the Turkish Penal Code should be evaluated. It is especially important that the vehicle belongs to a bona fide third party, how it was used in the crime, and whether the legal conditions for confiscation are met.

The decision of the General Criminal Assembly of the Supreme Court of Appeals, dated February 4, 2026, numbered 2024/160 E. and 2026/67 K., also contains important evaluations regarding the confiscation and the right to defense in the immigrant smuggling file.

If immigrant smuggling is carried out through a company, will the company also be punished?

The fourth paragraph of Article 79 of the Turkish Penal Code clearly regulates this issue.

If the crime of immigrant smuggling is committed within the scope of the activities of a legal entity, security measures specific to these may be imposed on the legal entity.

We are not talking about imprisonment for the company itself here. Criminal liability is evaluated in terms of real persons. In terms of legal entities, security measures stipulated in the law come to the fore.

For example, if an illegal immigration organization is carried out using the activities of a company, the activities of the company and the roles of the real persons involved are investigated.

The company's connection with crime, the resources used and the benefits obtained should also be examined.

Is it possible to be acquitted of the crime of immigrant smuggling?

Of course it is possible. Just because an investigation has been launched or an indictment has been issued against a person does not mean that he is guilty.

One of the most fundamental principles of criminal law is the presumption of innocence.

In order for a person to be punished, it must be demonstrated with legal evidence that the legal elements of the crime have been formed and that the accused act was committed by the defendant.

For example, the suspect's presence in the vehicle, his acquaintance with foreign nationals, or his making a phone call related to the incident are not sufficient for conviction.

If the purpose of obtaining material benefit cannot be proven, if it cannot be proven that the person participated in an illegal crossing organization, or if the evidence was obtained by illegal methods, an acquittal decision may be on the agenda.

Each file must be evaluated within its own evidence structure.

If a conviction is given, can the decision be appealed?

Yes. Legal remedies may be taken against the decisions of the criminal court, under the conditions specified in the law.

As a rule, an application for regional appellate review of a first-instance judgment must be made within two weeks of service of the reasoned judgment.

Decisions of the Regional Court of Appeal may be subject to review by the Court of Cassation depending on the nature of the decision and the conditions for appeal on points of law set out in the Code of Criminal Procedure (CMK).

In this process, mistakes made in determining the punishment, evaluation of evidence, restriction of the right of defense, use of illegal evidence and whether the elements of the crime are present can be examined.

It is of great importance not to miss the legal remedy deadlines.

IMPORTANT WARNING FROM LAWYER GİZEM GONCE

Immigrant smuggling is not just an issue related to border security. It is also a crime that has serious consequences for international criminal organizations, human life, fundamental rights of individuals and criminal justice.

In particular, transporting foreign nationals illegally, housing them in dangerous conditions, and organizing them for financial gain may result in severe criminal sanctions.

However, it should not be forgotten that in criminal law, each incident must be evaluated within its own circumstances. Helping a foreigner, transporting him with a vehicle or sheltering him in his home does not alone constitute the crime of immigrant smuggling. The purpose of the material benefit sought by the law, the unlawful act and the intent of the perpetrator must be demonstrated with concrete evidence.

What is important is not only whether a person is involved in the incident, but also whether the legal elements of the crime are met for that person. In criminal proceedings, legal evidence and personal responsibility are essential, not assumptions.

Penalty limits are determined by taking into account the legal provisions on the date of the crime and the favorable legal evaluation.

Official sources and legislation

Back to blog