YARGITAY'DAN EV SAHİPLERİNİ ÜZECEK KARAR! — Av. Gizem Gonce

A Decision from the Court of Cassation That Will Disappoint Landlords!

If the tenant vacates the property, will the landlord pay the litigation costs?

A notable decision has been rendered by the Court of Cassation regarding tenancy disputes between tenants and landlords. The 3rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation ruled that if the tenant vacates the property in compliance with statutory conditions before the commencement of the new tenancy period while a rent determination lawsuit is ongoing, and if the lawsuit consequently becomes devoid of purpose (moot), the litigation costs must be imposed on the landlord.

So, under which circumstances does this decision apply? Will landlords now bear all the expenses of the lawsuits they initiate? Will tenants be able to vacate the property at any time and be relieved of litigation costs?

We ask all these questions to Attorney at Law Gizem Gonce.

Ms. Gonce, what is the essence of this decision rendered by the Court of Cassation? What kind of outcome awaits landlords?

ATTORNEY AT LAW GİZEM GONCE:

Here, first of all, we need to correctly understand the scope of the decision. The assessment of the Court of Cassation does not mean that landlords will pay the costs of all lawsuits they bring.

The decision in question relates to the situation where, after a rent determination lawsuit has been filed, the tenant terminates the tenancy contract in accordance with statutory conditions and vacates the immovable property before the new tenancy period begins.

It is stated that if the lawsuit becomes moot for this reason, the tenant cannot be held liable for litigation costs merely because a lawsuit was initiated. In this specific situation, litigation costs are left to be borne by the landlord.

Well, why does a landlord file a rent determination lawsuit? For what purpose are these lawsuits filed?

ATTORNEY AT LAW GİZEM GONCE:

A rent determination lawsuit is initiated to enable the determination by the court of the rental fee to be applied between the parties.

A dispute may arise between the parties, particularly when there are significant differences between the current rental fee and comparable rental values of the property.

The landlord may claim the determination of the rental fee within the framework of the conditions stipulated by the law. However, the tenant also has the right to terminate the lease contract in accordance with the law.

The point emphasized by the Court of Cassation is that the landlord's right of action does not extinguish the tenant's statutory rights.

What happens if the tenant vacates the property while the rent determination lawsuit is ongoing?

ATTORNEY AT LAW GİZEM GONCE:

There are two important matters here. The first is that the tenant's act of terminating the contract must be in accordance with the law. The second is that the vacatur must take place before the new tenancy period commences.

If the tenant terminates the contract by complying with the required notice requirements and vacates the immovable before the new period begins, the lawsuit aimed at determining the rental fee for the new period may become moot.

The Court of Cassation states that the tenant's exercise of a statutory right cannot be interpreted per se as giving cause to the filing of the lawsuit.

For this reason, under the specified conditions, imposing litigation costs on the tenant is not found to be in accordance with the law.

The headline of the decision states 'The landlord will pay all expenses.' Will all expenses really belong to the landlord?

ATTORNEY AT LAW GİZEM GONCE:

A distinction needs to be made at this point. Although the headline of the news is striking, the legal scope of the decision is limited.

What is at issue here are the litigation costs and the statutory adverse party attorney's fee in a specific rent determination lawsuit that has become moot.

The decision does not mean that the landlord will automatically pay the costs of every lawsuit filed. Each dispute must be evaluated within its own circumstances.

Consequently, the landlords' right to file a lawsuit has not been eliminated. However, when initiating a lawsuit, it is important that they take into account the nature of the dispute and its potential legal consequences.

Does the tenant need to give notice to the landlord before vacating the property?

ATTORNEY AT LAW GİZEM GONCE:

Yes, this matter is quite important.

Pursuant to Article 347 of the Turkish Code of Obligations, in fixed-term residential and roofed workplace tenancy contracts, the tenant may prevent the extension of the contract by giving notice at least 15 days prior to the end of the contractual term.

However, the form of the notice, its time limit, and the characteristics of the contract must be evaluated separately in the concrete case.

The mere fact that the tenant has vacated the property does not mean that the tenancy relationship has legally terminated in every case. For this reason, the vacatur process must be conducted in accordance with procedure.

What could be the economic consequences of this decision for the landlord?

ATTORNEY AT LAW GİZEM GONCE:

Before filing a lawsuit, the landlord should evaluate the nature of the dispute, the rental fee claimed, and whether the tenant will continue the contract.

Because the tenant's vacating of the immovable in accordance with statutory conditions while the lawsuit is ongoing may render the rent determination lawsuit regarding the new tenancy period moot.

In this case, the landlord may face financial consequences such as statutory adverse party attorney's fees in addition to certain disbursements made for the lawsuit.

However, it should not be forgotten here that each case file has its own specific circumstances and that the relevant court decision will serve as the basis for determining costs.

Can this decision be considered an important safeguard for tenants?

ATTORNEY AT LAW GİZEM GONCE:

The decision is of importance particularly for tenants who terminate their contracts in accordance with statutory conditions while a rent determination lawsuit is ongoing.

It is important that it has been emphasized that the tenant cannot automatically be held liable for litigation costs merely because of having exercised a statutory right.

Nevertheless, this decision does not mean that tenants will be exempt from lawsuit costs in every circumstance. The outcome may vary in a different legal dispute or under different conditions.

For this reason, both tenants and landlords must act with awareness of their rights and obligations.

Finally, what would you advise landlords and tenants?

ATTORNEY AT LAW GİZEM GONCE:

I advise both landlords and tenants to secure their rights in tenancy relationships through written documents.

When tenants wish to terminate the contract, they should observe the statutory notice periods and conduct the vacatur process in accordance with procedure.

As for landlords, prior to filing a rent determination lawsuit, they should assess the legal conditions, the course of litigation, and possible financial consequences.

Most importantly, it must be recognized that not every dispute will conclude in the same manner. Conducting a legal evaluation according to the circumstances of the concrete case is of great importance in terms of preventing potential future financial losses.

This decision of the Court of Cassation brings clarity to the debate regarding upon whom litigation costs will be imposed following the tenant's vacatur in rent determination lawsuits.

However, there is an important detail that must not be forgotten: The decision demonstrates not that the costs of all lawsuits will belong to the landlord, but that, in rent determination lawsuits that have become moot under specific conditions, the expenses must be imposed on the lessor.

In order to avoid loss of rights, tenants and landlords must carefully monitor lease contracts, notice periods, and vacatur procedures.

28 October 2026 update — New questions and explanations

Who Pays the Costs of a Rent Determination Case?

Attorney Gizem Gonce commented: “A tenant’s exercise of a statutory right to terminate the tenancy is not, by itself, sufficient to make the tenant liable for litigation costs.”

Litigation costs have come into focus in rent disputes between tenants and landlords. The 3rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation ruled that, where a rent determination case brought before the new rental period becomes moot because the tenant lawfully terminates the lease and vacates the property, litigation costs cannot be imposed on the tenant.

This assessment is significant to the debate over which party should bear costs in rent determination cases.

Attorney Gizem Gonce explains that rent proceedings require consideration not only of the fact that a case was brought, but also of why the dispute ended and how the parties acted in legal terms.

Attorney Gizem Gonce answers questions

What happens if the tenant moves out after the landlord brings a rent determination case?

Attorney Gizem Gonce: The purpose of a rent determination case is to establish the rent through legal proceedings. However, if the tenant duly terminates the lease and will not use the property during the new rental period, a case concerning the rent for that future period may become moot.

This is not an automatic outcome. The date of vacation, the way the lease was terminated and the characteristics of the rental period concerned must be assessed together.

Must a tenant pay all litigation costs upon moving out?

Attorney Gizem Gonce: No. It cannot be said that costs must be imposed on the tenant after every vacation of a property. In the Court of Cassation’s assessment, litigation costs cannot be imposed on a tenant in a rent determination case that becomes moot because the tenant exercised a statutory right to terminate the lease.

However, this does not mean that landlords must pay the costs in every rent dispute. The court considers the circumstances of the particular case and why the proceedings became moot.

What should a tenant do to move out before the new rental period begins?

Attorney Gizem Gonce: The tenant should first examine the lease term and the provisions governing notice of termination. Under Article 347 of the Turkish Code of Obligations, a tenant under a fixed-term residential or roofed workplace lease may prevent its renewal by giving notice at least fifteen days before the term expires.

It is important to give notice on time and in a manner that can be proved. Merely vacating the property does not necessarily mean that the lease has ended with all its legal consequences.

What does this decision mean for tenants?

Attorney Gizem Gonce: The significant point is that a tenant’s exercise of a statutory right cannot, by itself, be interpreted against the tenant. Nevertheless, tenants should follow proceedings once a case is brought, retain documents relating to their departure and submit them to the court if necessary.

Timely notices and documented steps can matter not only for vacating the property but also for litigation costs and recoverable attorney fees.

Who bears the costs of a rent determination case is not determined solely by the fact that proceedings were brought. The reason the dispute ended and the parties’ legal conduct must be assessed together.

Back to blog