YARGITAY’DAN KİRA TESPİT DAVALARINDA EMSAL KARAR — Av. Aylin Esra Eren

PRECEDENT DECISION FROM THE COURT OF CASSATION IN RENT DETERMINATION LAWSUITS

In vacated houses, litigation expenses may remain with the landlord

A noteworthy decision has emerged from the Court of Cassation in rent determination lawsuits. The 3rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation ruled that in cases where the leased immovable is vacated before the new rental period begins, the tenant cannot be held liable for litigation expenses and attorney fees. The decision has brought an important legal debate to the fore regarding which party should bear the litigation expenses in rent determination lawsuits.

Evaluating the matter, Attorney Aylin Esra Eren explained the potential consequences of the decision for tenants and landlords, as well as the points to consider in practice.

Why is this decision of the Court of Cassation important for rent determination lawsuits?

ATTORNEY AYLIN ESRA EREN: In rent determination lawsuits, not only what the new rental fee will be, but also which party will bear the litigation expenses and attorney fees can be a significant matter of dispute. In particular, the tenant vacating the immovable while proceedings are continuing or before the new rental period begins can render the legal status of the lawsuit and to whom the expenses will be allocated controversial.

The approach of the 3rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation on this matter is important in terms of demonstrating that in cases where the tenant terminates the lease agreement by exercising their statutory right, litigation expenses cannot be automatically imposed on the tenant. However, it must also be noted that each concrete case must be evaluated within its own circumstances.

If the tenant leaves the house before the new rental period begins, what will be the outcome of the rent determination lawsuit?

ATTORNEY AYLIN ESRA EREN: Here, it is primarily necessary to look at the date on which the evacuation occurred, when the lease agreement ended, and for which rental period the lawsuit was filed.

Rent determination lawsuits pertain to determining the rental fee to be applied in a specific rental period. The tenant vacating the immovable in accordance with the law before the new rental period begins may affect the legal basis of the dispute and the outcome of the lawsuit.

In this case, the court must evaluate whether the lawsuit has become devoid of purpose and to which party litigation expenses should be allocated according to the particularities of the concrete case. The tenant merely being the defendant is not sufficient on its own to hold them liable for litigation expenses.

According to the decision, why are litigation expenses and attorney fees imposed on the landlord?

ATTORNEY AYLIN ESRA EREN: When evaluating to whom the litigation expenses and attorney fees will be allocated, the circumstances giving rise to the filing of the lawsuit, the conduct of the parties, and the reason for which the dispute ended are taken into consideration.

If the tenant properly terminated the agreement by exercising the right granted to them by law and vacated the immovable, holding them liable for expenses merely because they are a party to the rent determination lawsuit may not be correct.

The approach highlighted in the Court of Cassation decision also demonstrates the importance of this distinction. Nevertheless, imposing litigation expenses on the landlord should not be considered an absolute rule to be applied automatically in every rent determination lawsuit. The court must consider the particularities of the concrete case and the relevant procedural provisions together.

What kind of advantage will this decision provide for tenants?

ATTORNEY AYLIN ESRA EREN: The decision is especially important for tenants who terminate the lease agreement within the legal framework and vacate the immovable before the new rental period begins.

For tenants, the most critical point—in addition to the immovable having been vacated—is that the legal conditions and date of the evacuation are provable. The date of evacuation, key delivery, correspondence between the parties, and, if any, evacuation protocols may carry importance in resolving the dispute.

Nevertheless, tenants should not conclude, based on this decision, that they will not pay litigation expenses under any circumstances. The circumstances of every lawsuit are different, and the allocation of expenses is determined according to the particularities of the case file.

What should landlords pay attention to when filing a rent determination lawsuit?

ATTORNEY AYLIN ESRA EREN: Landlords must primarily file the rent determination lawsuit for the correct period, observe the conditions of the lawsuit and statutory deadlines, and support their claims regarding the determination of the rental fee with legal and concrete evidence.

In addition, the possibility of the tenant terminating the agreement and how the lawsuit will be affected in the event that the immovable is vacated must also be taken into account. Because having filed a rent determination lawsuit does not mean that the requested rental fee will be accepted under all circumstances or that litigation expenses will be imposed on the tenant.

What is important for landlords is to accurately assess the legal situation and take potential outcomes into account before filing a lawsuit.

Can this decision be considered the beginning of a new era in tenancy disputes?

ATTORNEY AYLIN ESRA EREN: The decision should be viewed as an important evaluation regarding the determination of litigation expenses in rent determination lawsuits. Especially in situations where the tenant terminates the agreement using their statutory right and vacates the immovable, it can provide guidance on the principles according to which liability for expenses will be determined.

However, it would not be correct to say that a decision will be applied in the same manner to all tenancy disputes. The scope, reasoning, and connection of the decision to the concrete case are important. In practice, courts must evaluate the termination date of the lease agreement, the subject matter of the lawsuit, and the conduct of the parties together.

Finally, what would you recommend to tenants and landlords?

ATTORNEY AYLIN ESRA EREN: Both tenants and landlords must not focus solely on financial claims in tenancy disputes, but must also take procedural rules and statutory deadlines into account.

Tenants, while terminating the agreement, must fulfill their statutory notification obligations and document the evacuation and key delivery processes. Landlords, on the other hand, before filing a rent determination lawsuit, must carefully evaluate which period the lawsuit covers and the legal status of the immovable.

In disputes arising over litigation expenses and attorney fees, all events taking place from the date the lawsuit was filed until the date of evacuation may carry importance. For this reason, it is important for the parties to seek legal assistance suitable to their concrete cases in order to prevent additional costs that may arise in the future.

CONCLUSION: The decision of the 3rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation regarding evacuation and litigation expenses in rent determination lawsuits stands out as a noteworthy development regarding the rights and obligations of tenants and landlords. In the application of the decision to concrete cases, the date of evacuation, the terms of termination of the agreement, and the legal status of the lawsuit continue to remain decisive.

Back to blog