Yeni kira sözleşmesi imzalanınca beş yıllık süre her zaman yeniden mi başlar? — Av. Aylin Esra Eren

Does the five-year period always restart when a new lease is signed?

Summary: In a workplace dispute involving a tenancy that had continued for many years, the Court of Cassation emphasized that it must be investigated whether the rent set in a later agreement was consistent with comparable rents and market rates.

In rent determination cases, the five-year period is an important legal benchmark for landlords and tenants. However, signing a new agreement in a long-standing tenancy does not necessarily mean that all consequences of the previous relationship have disappeared.

In its decision numbered E. 2025/3450, K. 2026/1141, the 3rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation stated that it must be investigated whether the rent set in the renewed agreement was consistent with comparable rents and market rates at the time the agreement was made.

Attorney Aylin Esra Eren discussed the dispute over time limits in rent determination cases.

Question: Can a rent determination lawsuit be filed before five years have passed?

Attorney Aylin Esra Eren: As a general rule, Article 344 of the Turkish Code of Obligations addresses the five-year period for determining rent and the assessment criteria that apply after that period. However, if a new agreement has been drawn up in a long-standing tenancy, the legal nature of that agreement and whether the agreed rent reflects the market rate at that time may become important. The approach in the Court of Cassation decision shows that a conclusion should not be reached solely by looking at the date of the new agreement without investigating the specific circumstances.

Question: Does making a new contract mean that the old tenancy has ended?

Attorney Aylin Esra Eren: Not always. It should be assessed whether the document's content and the parties' intent indicate that they meant to end the previous relationship, and whether the relationship continued in practice. The mere existence of a newly dated document does not prove in every case that a new and independent tenancy began.

Question: What factors are considered when determining rent?

Attorney Aylin Esra Eren: The property's location, nature and intended use, comparable rents, the history of the agreement, and the legal criteria applicable to the relevant period are assessed. Where an expert examination is required, it is important that the report rely on specific, comparable properties.

Five years and comparable rents in rent determination

Under Article 344(3), after five years the court considers the twelve-month average CPI change, the property’s condition, comparable rents and equity. In assessing a later agreement, continuity of the lease and whether the new rent matched comparable rents at that time may matter.

Official source

Back to blog