Contractor and Building Inspection Liability for Buildings That Collapse in an Earthquake
This article provides general information. Legislation, time limits and amounts may change over time; obtain an up-to-date assessment of your specific situation.
In investigations concerning buildings that collapsed in an earthquake, expert reports, building inspection, and the liability of public officials play an important role. Attorney Gizem Gonce emphasized that criminal liability depends not only on a person’s title but also on an assessment of specific fault and causation.
If a building collapses in an earthquake, is the contractor held directly liable?
Attorney Gizem Gonce: The fact that a building has collapsed does not, by itself, mean that a particular person’s criminal liability has been established. It must be investigated whether the building was constructed in accordance with the project, what materials were used, how inspections were carried out, whether there were regulatory violations, and whether there is a causal link between those violations and the collapse.
The liability of the contractor, technical professionals, building inspection organizations, and other relevant persons is assessed separately, based on their assigned duties and specific fault.
Can a building inspection company also be held liable?
Attorney Gizem Gonce: Liability may arise if it is established that inspection obligations arising under the relevant legislation were breached and that the breach is legally connected to the outcome. However, it would not be accurate to say that every building inspection company will automatically be held liable to the same extent in every collapse.
How is the liability of public officials determined?
Attorney Gizem Gonce: For public officials, their duties and authority, inspection obligations, specific acts or omissions, and their connection to the incident must be examined. Relevant investigation and authorization procedures may also apply. Accordingly, in addition to identifying technical fault, it is necessary to determine which person’s liability is based on which legal duty.
It has been reported concerning the Tutar Yapı Sitesi case in Adana that an expert report pointed to an inspection failure by the municipality, but the responsible personnel could not be identified. In such cases, the distinction between technical findings and individual legal liability is particularly important.
What legal avenues may families who have lost relatives pursue?
Attorney Gizem Gonce: Depending on the circumstances, joining the criminal investigation, claims for pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages, and other legal avenues may be considered. Building permits, plans, inspection documents, expert reports, and records in the investigation file are important. Filing deadlines and the competent judicial route must also be examined separately in light of the nature of the case.
Criminal liability and liability for pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages are not the same. Each is assessed under its own conditions and evidence.
How are technical findings and liability assessed?
The inquiry considers the building permit, approved plans, geotechnical report, material test results and dated inspection records together. If a load-bearing element differs from the approved plan, investigators examine when the deviation occurred, who was responsible at that stage, and whether it contributed to the collapse. Later alterations are also examined.
Article 3 of Turkish Law No. 4708 provides for liability in proportion to fault towards the building owner and the relevant authority for building damage within its scope. A criminal investigation considers each person's duties, conduct and link to the outcome individually. If there is a death or injury, criminal negligence provisions may apply depending on the circumstances. A damages claim requires an assessment of loss and causation under the applicable legal basis.
Building Inspection Law, Articles 2–3, Turkish Criminal Code, Arts. 20, 22, 85 and 89.