Court of Cassation Precedent Has Changed: The Legal Status of Third Parties in Construction Contracts in Return for Land Share
This article provides general information. Legislation, time limits and amounts may change over time; obtain an up-to-date assessment of your specific situation.
Attorney at Law Gizem Gonce: “Reliance on the Land Registry and the Property Rights of Good-Faith Third Parties Have Been Placed Under Stronger Protection”
In construction contracts in return for land share, in the event that the contractor fails to complete the construction or the contract is terminated with retroactive effect, the legal status of third parties who purchase independent units from the contractor has been a subject of debate for many years. With the decision of the Grand General Assembly of the Court of Cassation for the Unification of Judgments dated 16 May 2025, numbered Merits 2024/1 and Decision 2025/2, a significant change was made to the established precedent in this field.
With the new decision, it has been accepted that the good-faith claims of persons who purchase immovable property or land shares from the contractor appearing as the owner in the land registry must be evaluated, and when the conditions are met, their property rights must be protected. However, this protection is not applied in every case and unconditionally. Whether the third party acted in good faith is evaluated according to the specific characteristics of the concrete case.
Attorney at Law Gizem Gonce, whose assessments on the subject we obtained, addressed the significance of the change in precedent in terms of landowners, residential property buyers, and contractual practices in the real estate sector.
Ms. Gonce, first of all, what is a construction contract in return for land share? Why is this type of contract subject to so many disputes?
Attorney at Law Gizem Gonce:
A construction contract in return for land share, also frequently known in practice as a construction contract in return for flat, is a type of contract established between the landowner and the contractor. In this contract, the landowner undertakes to transfer certain land shares or independent units to the contractor who undertakes to carry out construction on the immovable property belonging to the landowner. The contractor, in turn, is obliged to complete the agreed construction in accordance with the contract.
In this contract model, the contractor may sell to third parties the independent units or land shares to be allocated to them in order to secure financing for the construction. However, in the event of failure to complete the construction, default by the contractor, or termination of the contract, serious legal problems may arise.
For example, a person may have purchased an apartment from the contractor and obtained the title deed in their own name. Subsequently, on the grounds that the contractor failed to complete the construction, the landowner may request the retroactive termination of the contract. In this case, the fundamental question is: Can the landowner demand the cancellation of the third party's title deed due to the contractor's non-performance of their obligation?
The Court of Cassation's decision on the unification of judgments has brought a significant change precisely in resolving this question.
Which legal approach changed with the Court of Cassation's new decision?
Attorney at Law Gizem Gonce:
In the established approach adopted prior to the Court of Cassation's decision on the unification of judgments dated 16 May 2025, the contractor was mostly evaluated vis-à-vis the landowner's rights arising from the contract, and third parties acquiring immovable property from the contractor were also deemed dependent on their legal status.
Within the framework of this approach, in the event that the contractor failed to complete the construction and the contract was terminated retroactively, the reclamation of the land shares previously transferred to the contractor and the cancellation of transfers made to third parties could come to the agenda. There was also a restrictive approach regarding the evaluation of the good-faith claims of third parties.
With the new decision, it has been accepted that whether third parties acquiring rights in rem from the contractor appearing as the owner in the land registry are protected within the scope of Article 1023 of the Turkish Civil Code must be evaluated.
The point that needs to be particularly emphasized here is that the acquisitions of third parties who acquired property rights in good faith by relying on the land registry cannot be automatically eliminated solely due to the invalidity or retroactive termination of the contract between the landowner and the contractor.
Nonetheless, it should not be concluded that every third party will be protected automatically. Whether good faith exists must be examined according to the circumstances of the concrete case.
What does this decision mean for citizens purchasing residential units from a contractor?
Attorney at Law Gizem Gonce:
The decision is of significance particularly for persons who purchase titled independent units from the contractor. This is because, even though these persons were not parties to the contract between the landowner and the contractor, they could be affected by disputes arising from the termination of the contract.
The new precedent constitutes an important legal basis toward the protection of the property rights of persons who acquire rights in rem relying on the land registry and are deemed to act in good faith.
However, our citizens should not interpret this decision as “If I have obtained the title deed in my name, I no longer have any risk.” The conditions under which the sale was made, the entries in the land registry, whether the buyer knew of the dispute, and other concrete circumstances continue to be important.
Particularly at the stage of purchase, one should not be content solely with examining the title deed record; the legal status of the immovable property, annotations and encumbrances, if any, the construction servitude or condominium ownership status, and the relevant provisions of the contract concluded by the contractor with the landowner should be researched to the extent possible.
Well, does this decision mean a loss of rights for landowners?
Attorney at Law Gizem Gonce:
It would not be correct to evaluate the decision solely as a regulation against landowners. The aim here is to establish a balance between the landowner's rights arising from the contract and the property rights of third parties and the trust placed in the land registry.
The landowner may, of course, assert their rights arising from the contract in the event that the contractor fails to complete the construction. However, in terms of the immovable properties previously transferred by the contractor to third parties, whether the rights in rem of these persons will be protected must be evaluated separately.
If it emerges that the third party was not in good faith, knew the legal status of the immovable property, or that circumstances not supporting the claim of good faith were present in the concrete case, a different legal conclusion may be reached.
Therefore, the rights of landowners have not ceased to exist. Nevertheless, acting with greater diligence when concluding the contract and carrying out title deed transfers is of great importance for the prevention of disputes that may arise in the future.
Why is the concept of good faith so important in this decision? How will courts evaluate good faith?
Attorney at Law Gizem Gonce:
Good faith is one of the fundamental concepts in terms of the acquisition of immovable property ownership. Article 1023 of the Turkish Civil Code regulates the protection of this acquisition by a third party who acquires ownership or another right in rem by relying in good faith on the registration in the land registry.
However, the evaluation of good faith does not depend solely on the person defining themselves as acting in good faith. The characteristics of the concrete case must be examined.
For example, whether the person purchasing the immovable property examined the records in the land registry, whether they were aware of existing legal disputes, the conditions under which the sale was conducted, and other relevant evidence may be of importance in the evaluation.
It is not possible to speak of a single standard criterion applicable to every case here. The court will render its decision by taking into account the characteristics of the dispute and the evidence submitted by the parties.
For this reason, the decision on the unification of judgments should be understood not as a regulation protecting all third parties unconditionally, but as a change in approach ensuring the protection of good-faith acquisitions of rights in rem within the legal framework.
What precautions should landowners take at the contract stage to avoid encountering such disputes?
Attorney at Law Gizem Gonce:
In order for landowners to reduce risks, they must first correctly determine legal security mechanisms at the stage of drafting the contract.
I would like to draw attention particularly to several matters:
Gradual performance of title deed transfers: It should be evaluated to transfer the land shares to be transferred to the contractor gradually, in accordance with the completion level of the construction and the conditions specified in the contract.
Annotation of the contract in the land registry: To the extent permitted by legislation, annotating personal rights arising from the contract in the land registry should be considered. However, the scope of the annotation and its effect on third parties must be evaluated according to the concrete case; it cannot be said that the annotation automatically and absolutely eliminates every kind of good-faith claim.
Security mechanisms: The establishment of mortgages or other legal securities appropriate to the nature of the contract may be evaluated.
Clear determination of sale and transfer conditions: At what stage and which independent units or land shares the contractor may transfer should be explicitly regulated in the contract.
Legal review of the contract: The rights and obligations of the parties, termination conditions, cases of default, and the provisions to be applied in the event of a dispute should be addressed in detail while the contract is being drafted.
What is important here is not merely signing a contract, but identifying the risks that the contract may produce in advance and taking appropriate legal precautions.
What should persons who will purchase residential property from a contractor pay attention to?
Attorney at Law Gizem Gonce:
The most important matter for residential property buyers is to research the legal status of the immovable property prior to the sale.
First of all, the title deed record and mortgages, attachments, annotations, and other encumbrances on the immovable property should be examined. The seller's authority to transfer the immovable property and the legal status of the independent unit should be verified.
If construction is not yet completed, the status of the contract between the contractor and the landowner, at what stage the construction is, and the conformity of the independent unit subject to the sale with the allocation arrangement in the contract are also important.
Particularly in high-value immovable property purchases, the review of the sales contract and title deed records by an attorney practicing in the field of real estate law may assist in identifying potential risks in advance.
Although the new precedent provides significant protection for good-faith buyers, it is not a guarantee that renders purchasing immovable property safe without conducting a legal examination.
What could be the possible effects of this decision on the real estate sector and construction financing?
Attorney at Law Gizem Gonce:
Construction contracts in return for land share are an important part of real estate development models in Turkey. Contractors can transfer independent units or land shares allocated to them to third parties in order to secure financing for projects.
Following these sales, how the acquisitions of third parties will be evaluated in the event of retroactive termination of the contract is important both for the legal security of buyers and for the predictability of real estate transactions.
The new precedent may contribute to transaction security in terms of being based on the protection of good-faith persons who acquire rights in rem by relying on the land registry. Along with this, it also necessitates that landowners establish contractual and security mechanisms more carefully.
For this reason, the effect of the decision should not be evaluated solely through buyers or landowners. In terms of drafting contracts, planning title deed transfers, project financing, and managing legal risks, it is important for all parties to review their practices.
Could the decision also affect lawsuits for the cancellation and registration of title deeds that were previously filed or are ongoing?
Attorney at Law Gizem Gonce:
When evaluating the effect of the decision on the unification of judgments on concrete disputes, matters such as the subject of the lawsuit, its legal basis, which stage the proceedings are at, and by which transaction the immovable property was transferred to the third party must be taken into account.
Particularly in disputes where there are third parties who have acquired ownership or another right in rem in the land registry from the contractor, it is important to take the new precedent and the good-faith evaluation into consideration.
Nonetheless, it cannot be said that all lawsuits will yield the same outcome. The legal status of a person who acquired a right in rem from the contractor via title deed transfer and a person who has not yet acquired ownership and has merely taken over a personal receivable or right may be different from one another.
For this reason, one should not be content with a general evaluation regarding an ongoing lawsuit; the contracts, title deed records, and other evidence in the file must be examined together.
Finally, what is the most important message this change in precedent seeks to convey to citizens?
Attorney at Law Gizem Gonce:
The most important message of this decision is that, in real estate law, reliance on the land registry, property rights, and rights arising from contract must be evaluated together.
On one side, there is the landowner's right to demand that the contractor act in accordance with the contract and perform their own obligations. On the other side, there is the property right of the third party who acquired the immovable property in good faith from the person appearing as the owner in the land registry.
The Court of Cassation's decision on the unification of judgments has brought about a significant change in establishing the balance between these two legal interests.
My advice to our citizens is not to focus solely on the purchase price and the title deed transfer in real estate purchase and sale transactions. The legal nature of the contract, title deed records, annotations and encumbrances, if any, and the rights and obligations of the parties should be carefully examined prior to the transaction.
In preventing legal disputes, the most effective method is not seeking a solution after the problem arises, but taking the necessary legal precautions at the stage of the contract and transaction.