Yükleniciden Daire Alan İyiniyetli Alıcının Tapusu Korunur mu? — Eren & Gonce Hukuk Gündemi

Third Parties' Title Deed Rights in Construction in Return for Land Share

Attorney Aylin Esra Eren: “In construction contracts in return for land share, the title deed rights of third parties cannot be evaluated independently of the legal validity of the contract”

Construction contracts in return for land share closely concern not only the commercial relationship between the landowner and the contractor, but also the property rights of third parties who purchase independent sections from the project. Situations such as termination of the contract, the contractor's failure to perform its obligations, or the transfer of the title deed losing its legal basis can cause serious loss of rights for good faith purchasers. Attorney Aylin Esra Eren evaluated the legal consequences of construction contracts in return for land share, the principle of reliance on the land registry, and under what conditions the rights of third parties can be protected.

Why are construction contracts in return for land share so important?

Question: Construction contracts in return for land share are one of the areas in real estate law where disputes arise most frequently. How do you evaluate the legal nature of these contracts?

Attorney Aylin Esra Eren: In practice, construction contracts in return for land share produce significant legal consequences for landowners, contractors, and third parties who purchase independent sections from the project. In these contracts, the landowner undertakes to transfer certain land shares or independent sections; the contractor undertakes to complete the agreed construction and fulfill its other obligations under the contract.

The point to be noted here is that the contract does not merely regulate the obligation relationship between the parties. The completion status of the construction, the stage at which title deed transfers are made, the validity of the contract, and the consequences of a possible termination or retroactive termination decision may also directly affect the property rights of third parties.

For this reason, all stages from the drafting of the contract to the title deed transfers must be carefully evaluated from a legal perspective.

Under what conditions are the title deed rights of third parties protected?

Question: Can the title deed right of a person who purchases an apartment from the contractor be affected by disputes that subsequently arise between the landowner and the contractor?

Attorney Aylin Esra Eren: Yes, in some cases it may be affected. However, it cannot be said that every dispute will eliminate the title deed right of the third party. The characteristics of the concrete case, the legal transaction on which the title deed transfer was based, the rights and authorities of the contractor under the contract, the level of construction, and the nature of the acquisition by the third party must be evaluated together.

In particular, the contractor's transfer of independent sections to which it has not yet acquired rights, or the termination of the contract made with the landowner, can lead to serious disputes between the parties. However, in the event that the third party acquires ownership by relying on the land registry, whether the principle of reliance on the land registry under Article 1023 of the Turkish Civil Code (TMK) will be applied must also be examined.

Here, good faith alone is not sufficient in every case. The title deed records of the real estate, annotations, known legal disputes, and the conditions under which the acquisition took place must be addressed together.

Is having the title deed transferred sufficient in every case?

Question: If a person has received the title deed in their name, can it be assumed that there is no longer any legal risk?

Attorney Aylin Esra Eren: Although the transfer of the title deed is an important legal guarantee, it does not mean that all risks are eliminated. The transaction through which the title deed was acquired, the disposing capacity of the transferring person, the entries in the land registry, and other characteristics of the case are of importance.

In Turkish law, the principle of reliance on the land registry protects third parties who acquire real rights under certain conditions. However, in order for this protection to apply, the conditions required by law must be met.

For example, where a record in the land registry is contrary to reality, the situation of a person who acquires ownership or another real right by relying on this record in good faith cannot be evaluated in the same way as the situation of a person who acquires the real estate despite knowing or being required to know the legal defect.

Therefore, purchasers must pay attention not only to the fact that the title deed has been registered in their names, but also to the legal basis of the acquisition and the records of the real estate.

How does the termination of the contract between the landowner and the contractor affect third parties?

Question: When the contract between the landowner and the contractor is terminated, do the rights of persons who purchased apartments from the contractor also come to an end?

Attorney Aylin Esra Eren: It is not possible to give a single answer to this question that is valid for all cases. The reason for the termination of the contract, the extent to which the parties fulfilled their obligations, the completion level of the construction, the timing of the title deed transfers, and the legal position of third parties are decisive.

First of all, it must be evaluated whether the contract produces prospective or retroactive effects. Restitution and compensation claims arising between the landowner and the contractor upon the termination of the contract are not the same matter as the fate of the real rights of third parties.

Particularly with respect to independent sections whose title deeds have been transferred, whether the ownership right of the third party will be protected must be examined separately. If the title deed transfer has not been carried out, the fact that the person relies solely on a preliminary contract for sale or a personal right may also alter the legal evaluation.

For this reason, termination of the contract should not be interpreted as automatically extinguishing the rights of all third parties. Each case file must be evaluated within its own circumstances.

What legal remedies can purchasers whose title deed transfer has not been carried out resort to?

Question: How should a person act who has made payment for their apartment but has not received their title deed?

Attorney Aylin Esra Eren: First of all, it must be determined which contract the person is party to and on what legal basis they base their claim. A sales contract concluded with the contractor, a preliminary contract for real estate sale, or a direct legal relationship established with the landowner may produce different results regarding the path to follow.

In such disputes, contracts, payment documents, title deed records, notarial documents if any, and records showing the current status of the construction must be examined together.

Depending on the circumstances of the concrete case, title deed cancellation and registration, refund of the price, compensation, or other legal claims may come onto the agenda. However, each claim has different conditions and legal limits.

To avoid loss of rights, it is important to preserve contracts and payment documents, examine title deed records, and obtain a legal evaluation without delay.

What should purchasers pay attention to before signing a contract?

Question: What precautions do you recommend to citizens who wish to purchase real estate?

Attorney Aylin Esra Eren: In purchasing real estate, focusing solely on the price and payment terms is not sufficient. The legal status of the real estate must also be investigated prior to the transaction.

In particular, I recommend paying attention to the following matters:

  • Title deed records: Who the owner of the real estate is, and whether there are mortgages, attachments, annotations, and other encumbrances must be checked.
  • Authority of the contractor: It must be examined whether the independent section subject to sale was left to the contractor and at what stage the contractor's right of disposal over this independent section arises.
  • Contractual provisions: The delivery date, payment plan, conditions of the title deed transfer, provisions to apply in case of delay, and arrangements regarding termination of the contract must be clear.
  • Status of the construction: The building permit, architectural project, and actual progress level of the construction must be investigated.
  • Documentation of payments: Payments made must be verifiable through bank records and other valid documentation.
  • Legal review: Especially in projects where construction has not yet been completed, having contracts and title deed records reviewed by a specialist lawyer contributes to preventing disputes that may arise in the future.

In real estate transactions, preventive legal review often provides more effective protection than seeking remedies after a dispute has arisen.

Why are court decisions important in these disputes?

Question: How do you evaluate the role of court decisions in construction contracts in return for land share?

Attorney Aylin Esra Eren: Disputes in this field are evaluated within the framework of the Turkish Code of Obligations (TBK), the Turkish Civil Code (TMK), and other regulations regarding real estate ownership, in addition to contractual provisions.

Court of Cassation decisions help in understanding the practice, especially regarding the consequences of the termination of the contract, the completion level of the construction, the mutual obligations of the parties, and the legal position of third parties.

However, it should not be assumed that any decision can be directly applied to a concrete dispute. The facts regarding which the decision was rendered, its legal reasoning, and its relationship with subsequent case law must be evaluated together.

Therefore, in legal disputes, it is necessary to look not only at the outcome of the decision, but also at the reasoning on which the decision is based and its similarities to the concrete case.

Final message: Legal protection in real estate transactions begins prior to the transaction

Question: When you evaluate the topic generally, what is the most important message you would like to give to citizens?

Attorney Aylin Esra Eren: Construction contracts in return for land share are complex legal relationships that intertwine the rights and obligations of multiple persons. Disputes arising in these relationships may affect not only the landowner and the contractor, but also persons who purchase independent sections from the project.

For this reason, examining the title deed record, correctly determining the legal nature of the contract, investigating the authority of the contractor, and documenting payments are of great importance.

Citizens should not make decisions based solely on commercial promises, particularly in projects that are not yet completed. Each transaction must be evaluated within its own legal conditions, and professional legal assistance should be obtained when necessary.

It should not be forgotten that one of the fundamental conditions for conducting secure transactions in real estate law is to protect rights not only after a dispute arises, but also when the transaction is being established.

Back to blog